Visit Wisconsin Supper Clubs While Staying At WisCottage

There is something to say for how comfortable a good supper club makes you feel and no one does supper clubs better than Wisconsin.

Here are a few Supper Clubs we have been to, some recommend more that others but all are worth experiencing. There is a list of items that make a supper club a supper club. I will try to list a few here and under the restaurant to give you an idea. I'll also list some of the extra bonuses of certain ones. Remember these are very popular, some may have extremely long waits to get into, just remember patience is a virtue, so make sure you go early. Some take reservations but not all.

  • Prime rib or Surf & Turf on Saturday Night
  • Fish Fry on Friday Night
  • Walleye and/or BBQ Ribs
  • Old Fashions
  • Salad Bar or Relish Tray on Table
  • Fast Service, they need to turn the tables. We have found the ability to get you out in under an hour.
  • Brandy Ice and Grasshoppers

ISHNALA SUPPER CLUB - Lake Delton 

In the language of the Winnebago Indian, Ishnala means "By Itself Alone"

SYMBOLIZED BY THE POINT OF ROCK EXTENDING INTO THE PEACEFUL WATER OF MIRROR LAKE, LONG BEFORE THE ARRIVAL OF THE FIRST SETTLERS, ISHNALA WAS A CEREMONIAL GROUND FOR THE WINNEBAGO INDIANS.

Minutes from Wisconsin Dells, Ishnala Supper Club is nestled among the tall Norway Pines overlooking the majestic Mirror Lake in the middle of Mirror Lake State Park. At Ishnala Supper Club fine dining joins with nature to create a truly memorable dining experience. 

I won't give you the regular supper club list because there is nothing regular about Ishnala, here is the list that matters.

  • #1 Supper Club in Wisconsin 
  • #1 Old Fashioned 
  • #1 Destination
  • 2 bad things:
    • They are closed Oct. - April
    • Waits are typically 2 hours, so go before they open - really!
      • They have 4 bars to wait at, enjoy they view, an Ishnala Old Fashion, and the wonderful appetizers. Patience might be a virtue but with those 3 things it makes it a lot easier to be patient. 

"Additionally, we are proud to have reached a milestone of serving over 100,000 guests in 195 days with a 4.8 approval rating. Another incredible statistic for which we are thankful is the sale of 93,478 Old Fashioned cocktails in 2021." - Bob Prosser - Owner

Ishnala Supper Club

S2011 Ishnala Rd. Lake Delton
Ishnala Website - Menu
608-253-1771


CIMAROLI SUPPER CLUB - PORTAGE

I think this review says it best, "Once in a great while, you go to a restaurant that does everything right. This is that place... Good food and service, all the staff worked like a well oiled machine, and they seemed to enjoy working here. This was the best steak (and dining experience) I've had in a long time."

  • Prime Rib - every night
  • Fish Fry on Friday night
  • Old Fashions
  • Walleye & Ribs
  • Brandy Ice and Grasshoppers
  • Bonus - Flatiron Steaks, Shrimp Scampi and Escargot to die for.

No Reservations - First Come - First Served! Go early it is worth it!!!

Cimarolis Supper Club


W11793 WI-127, Portage 
Cimarolis Supper Club Website
Tuesday - Sunday 4pm

608 742 2238


Evergreens Supper Club - Black River Falls

A beautiful 45 minute drive from WisCottage. Supper club is back in the woods in a log cabin. Such a lovely location for a very comfortable evening of wonderful food and great service. Everything we had was fantastic. Highly Recommend!!! One of my top choices.

  • Prime rib on Saturday Night
  • Fish Fry on Friday Night
  • Old Fashions
  • Walleye & Ribs
  • Salad Bar
  • Brandy Ice & CobblersWisCottage Recommended Supper Club
    WisCottage Recommended Supper Club
    Evergreens Supper Club
    Evergreens Supper Club
  • Bonus - Location & Drive to it!
  • Bonus - Family Run
  • Note - They take only cash and checks - Internet issues - think backwoods. 

1095 Apollo Rd, Black River Falls

evergreenssupperclub.com

608-272-3202



House of the Embers

House of Embers is a traditional Wisconsin Supper Club. Enjoy the Dells unique fine dining experience in their main dining room or in a private romantic area for two. Enjoy summertime outdoor dining on their patio, featuring live music and a lounge.

935 Wisconsin Dells Parkway 

House of Embers


Wisconsin Dells

House of Embers Website

Phone: 608-253-6411



Crystal's Wood Lake Supper Club

WOW! Amazing Beer Battered Fish (Cod), all the other types I saw come out looked great, also. I believe it is the best I have ever had! Husband had the Pork Filets, and he loved them. It is a beautiful drive from WisCottage and worth it. They take reservations, mostly likely you will talk to Crystal on the phone. Extremely nice staff, the chef will most likely make his rounds to check in on what you thought about your meal. If you like duck you should try the duck strips, heck even if you don't like duck you should try them - yum! Highly Recommend! When I build my Best Wisconsin Fish Fry Google Map, I will add this to the top!


WisCottage Supper Club Map

We enjoy Wisconsin Supper Clubs so much, I have started a Google My Map of them. Some are in this area and some are farther south because we like to hit them on the way up from Illinois or or the way home.

Click box with arrow on top left of map to open the list of Supper Clubs. Click on the one you are interested in, it will come up on the map and the google information and website will appear. 

Ready to book a long supper club tasting weekend?

Here is a link if you would like to save outside our website - WisCottage - Wisconsin Supper Club

DI4Y Vacation Rentals BBB Business Review